Why is “Maryland” like a blind bird – because she can’t ‘See-Seed’ (Secede)
-Joke told by Samuel Epes Turner, Jr. to his father
Though Baltimore and Maryland were preserved for the Union, it was a victory won at gunpoint. Historian Harry Ezratty describes one occasion when Governor Dix, Butler’s successor in the Middle Department, demonstrated “a genuine display of gentlemanly tactfulness” and Victorian cunning when he invited overly influential local ladies to discuss matters of the occupation. According to his memoirs, he then pointed to a gun stationed at Fort McHenry and diplomatically asked his guests where it was directed. They observed that it was pointed to Battle Monument Square: a site of local importance commemorating the War of 1812. He promised them that if they stopped sowing the seeds of insurrection, there would be no more trouble. Otherwise, “that gun is the first that I shall fire.”
Samuel “Epes” and Clara Turner were strong supporters of the Union, but they understood how the sentiments of the war continued to tear apart their community. Both of the Turners had been born in Massachusetts, which helps account for their strong loyalty to the North. Epes was descended from the ninth president of Harvard – where his son would attend school during the war – while Clara was descended from Mayflower pilgrim John Alden. Most of their neighbors, however, were born and raised in the slave state of Maryland, and many would remain resentful toward their northern occupiers for the duration of the war.
It was no longer safe to openly lash out against the Union, but Confederate sympathizers were still vocal in their beliefs. “We have had considerable excitement here,” Epes wrote his cousins, “in consequence of our ‘Rebels’ rejoicing over the defeat of our first Maryland Regiment – and it resulted in a few of the scamps being knocked down.” Evidently, even small, personal rebellions were not tolerated by loyalist Baltimoreans emboldened by the presence of the United States Army.
The animosity came from both sides. Clara told one anecdote about a woman named Mrs. Streets who offered a friend one of her eleven American flags, one for each rebellious state, when she realized the friend did not have one hanging. When the friend declined, Streets promptly departed, leading Clara to conclude that Streets “cuts her secession friends without any ceremony.” And Epes himself declared that he would happily “go to Washington to see Jeff Davis hung” should the opportunity arrive. Before the Battle of Antietam, both Turners made it clear that they would sooner destroy Baltimore themselves than see it fall into the hands of the rebels.
But although the city remained highly divided, Baltimore was no longer a hotbed of rebellion. The barricades erected ahead of the Battle of Gettysburg were not for staging a rebellion, but for keeping out the Confederate invaders. Thankfully for the loyal Turner family and for the destiny of the Republic, Baltimore was kept for the Union. It simmered still with sectional tension, but its allegiance was made stable.
Ezratty, Harry A. Baltimore in the Civil War: The Pratt Street Riot and a City Occupied. Charleston: The History Press, 2010.
McKinney, Devin. “The Samuel E. and Clara Turner Paper, 1861-1865: A Report on Content, with Historical Notes.” January 2012. Samuel E. and Clara Turner papers, Gettysburg College Special Collections, Gettysburg College, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania.
Samuel E. and Clara Turner papers, MS-125, Gettysburg College Special Collections, Gettysburg College, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania.
“Fort McHenry, Baltimore, Md.” October 29, 1861. LC-USZ62-3677. Library of Congress.
Forbes, Edwin. “Scene in Baltimore, Md. Citizens building barricades on receipt of the news of Gen. Lee’s march into Penn.” June 28, 1863. LC-DIG-ppmsca-20546. Library of Congress.