By Lauren Letizia
War on the Doorstep: Civilians of Gettysburg
By late June of 1863, alarms warning of approaching Confederate forces were nothing new for the 2,400 residents of Gettysburg. Living just ten miles from the Mason-Dixon line, small-scale raids, kidnappings of freed-people, and rumors of an imminent clash between the two great armies had long plagued the borough and its surrounding community. Nevertheless, none of these events could prepare Gettysburgians for the ferocious 3-day fight between 165,000 soldiers in early July of that year that would transform the lives and lands of Gettysburg’s civilians forever. However, these civilians’ experiences were not monolithic; while some were defined by tragedy and blight, others included remarkable episodes of perseverance, successful pragmatism, and creative profiteering. This new blog series profiles the lives of diverse Gettysburgians who were forced to confront the war at their very doorsteps, each on their own terms, whose stories speak to the kaleidoscope of experiences of civilians struggling to survive, and thrive, along the Pennsylvania-Maryland border during the Civil War.
The surname Sherfy has been a pillar of the Gettysburg community for generations. It conjures up images of small, neat orchards, perfect peaches, and a devastating battle that forever altered the land. However, the story of the Sherfy family and their farm is also one of steadfastness, strength under pressure, and American ingenuity.
“The Sherfys of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania” was an established line well before their peaches became famous. They were descended from Kaspar Scherffig, a German immigrant farmer who came to Uniontown, Maryland in 1751 at the age of 16. His son, Jacob, was born in 1769, moved to southern Gettysburg, married a woman named Catherine, and raised eleven children. Their first home was built slightly farther south and to the east of the Emmitsburg Road than the red building now associated with their family. That first home is now called the Rose Farm. Sadly, Jacob and Catherine faced personal tragedy and death years before the Battle of Gettysburg. Their eldest son, Daniel, was thrown from a frightened horse and dragged through a tree thicket. Jacob was unable to stop the horse before Daniel died. In 1842, Jacob Sherfy passed away at the age of 73, passing the plot of land north of the Rose Farm to his son, Joseph. Joseph constructed the now iconic red brick house, and turned it into a homestead for himself and his wife Mary. They planted a four-acre peach orchard about 200 yards south of the home and expanded the orchard northward around 1862. Their farm also included a cherry tree grove and fields filled with oats, corn, and wheat, as well as hogs and other farm animals. In addition to tending his land, Joseph was a Dunker preacher. The Dunker faith was established in Germany during the early 18th Century. They espoused pietism, which means religion of the heart, and was closely aligned with Anabaptists, a religion that was against secularization of society and the conducting of warfare. As a core value of the Dunker religion, Joseph most likely subscribed to the belief in non-violent living and was likely greatly disturbed by the oncoming conflict. He and Mary had six children born between 1843 and 1860. Mary’s mother, known as Grandma Haegen, was also living with the Sherfy family at the time of the battle.
As the Union and Confederate armies thundered into Gettysburg, Joseph and Mary decided to send their children to safety south to the John Trostle Farm, located behind Big and Little Round Tops. However, either due to fears of unchecked destruction to the farm in their absence or a sense of stubborn pride, Grandma Haegen refused their pleas to leave the home, so Joseph and Mary elected to stay with her. On the morning of July 2, the sharpshooters of Colonel Hiram Berdan, under the command of General Daniel Sickles, found General Richard H. Anderson’s Confederate soldiers positioned in the woods behind the Sherfy Farm. A brief skirmish commenced, causing a bullet to burrow through a fence post, rip through the folds of Grandma Haegen’s dress, and land on the ground nearby. Haegen allegedly picked up the bullet and said, “It’s time to go to Taneytown!”
With the old woman’s approval, the Sherfys finally fled their farm, which would prove to be fortuitous. General Sickles, convinced that (at worst) General Robert E. Lee would push southward around the Federal flank toward Washington D.C, or that the Union defensive line would be far better suited along a forward salient anchored in the Sherfy’s peach orchard than it would be behind that critical high ground), ordered over 6,000 troops from his III Corps to advance from their original position along Cemetery Ridge and protect the Emmitsburg Road. There, Sickles established numerous batteries of southward-facing artillery to reinforce his one- and-a-quarter mile long line of infantry. Dangerously exposed along the open high ground and separated from the main Union lines, Sickles’s men were besieged by heavy Confederate artillery fire for approximately two and a half hours. Some of the shells and shrapnel collapsed portions of the Sherfys’ roof. Later in the evening, around 6:30pm, the advancing tide of William Barksdale’s Confederates finally broke through the Union lines along the Emmitsburg Road and, in tragic irony, the land of the peaceful Dunkards witnessed a bloodbath. The buildings were poked with bullet holes and the home began to fill with wounded and dying soldiers who were seeking protection. After the battle, survivors dug trenches around the farm to bury the dead and about 30 dead horses littered the torn land. Infamously, the Sherfy’s red barn caught fire during the fighting with scores of Union soldiers inside. It is not known how the barn ignited, but the fire could have been set deliberately by the 18th Mississippi to rout out possible Union sharpshooters, or simply could have fallen victim to a fiery shell. Most of the soldiers trapped in the barn were wounded men from the 73rd New York and the 57th and 68th Pennsylvania regiments. Due to the severity of their injuries sustained in battle, they were too weak to escape the inferno and ultimately perished.
After the gruesome battle, Joseph and his son Raphael returned to Gettysburg on July 6. They were forced to confront the barren and charred state of their family’s property. Not only were their buildings peppered with bullet holes and their barn completely destroyed, but the burnt bodies of the victim soldiers were gruesomely intermingled with the charred debris. It is estimated that 150 soldiers who were killed on or around the Sherfy farm were ultimately buried on the land. On July 7, Mary and the other children returned to witness the devastation. Joseph submitted three claims to the federal government after 1881 for compensation. The claims amounted to $2,500; they were mostly denied due to the government’s statement that much of the damage was not caused by the Union Army. The Sherfys, determined to reclaim their lives, started to rebuild all they lost. Remarkably, they were able to harvest peaches from the 114 surviving trees and canned them for sale. Joseph and Mary planned to use the earnings to pay for the reconstruction of the family homestead. They were baffled when their peach products began to fly off the shelves. Realizing a unique marketing strategy, the Sherfys branded their peaches as those grown on the iconic battlefield. The family continued to live on the property until Joseph’s death from typhoid at the age of 70.
The history of the Sherfy property is bloody, morbid, and macabre. The now deceptively picturesque landscape and red house, the tidy peach orchard, and quaint barn had once been transformed into a singed, ravaged, desolate tableau. The fate of the Sherfy property is one that many families’ homesteads around Gettysburg faced when the violence subsided. However, like some of their neighbors such as Lydia Leister and Nicholas Codori, the Sherfys did not let the bleak landscape and destruction discourage them from reaping future fortune. They immediately searched for innovative—and indeed, unlikely–ways to better their predicament and become self-sustaining once again. Their story exemplifies the power of determination, the benefits of flexibility, and the ingenuity of familial innovation. They made sweet (and financially fruitful) peach preserves out of war’s scorched orchards.


