Above the Call of Duty: Josephine Rogers (Josephine Miller)

By: Lauren Letizia

War on the Doorstep: Civilians of Gettysburg

By late June of 1863, alarms warning of approaching Confederate forces were nothing new for the 2,400 residents of Gettysburg. Living just ten miles from the Mason-Dixon line, small-scale raids, kidnappings of freed-people, and rumors of an imminent clash between the two great armies had long plagued the borough and its surrounding community.  Nevertheless, none of these events could prepare Gettysburgians for the ferocious 3-day fight between 165,000 soldiers in early July of that year that would transform the lives and lands of Gettysburg’s civilians forever. However, these civilians’ experiences were not monolithic; while some were defined by tragedy and blight, others included remarkable episodes of perseverance, successful pragmatism, and creative profiteering.  This new blog series profiles the lives of diverse Gettysburgians who were forced to confront the war at their very doorsteps, each on their own terms, whose stories speak to the kaleidoscope of experiences of civilians struggling to survive, and thrive, along the Pennsylvania-Maryland border during the Civil War.

It is often said that in hard times we discover the true characters of our neighbors. While some become distant and aloof during times of terrible hardship or fear, others demonstrate courage, kindness, and selflessness. The latter phenomenon is exemplified in the story of Gettysburg civilian, Josephine Rogers, also known as Josephine Miller. A young woman at the time of the great battle, she risked her own life to help young soldiers in need of sustenance and shelter.  Interestingly, as she did so, she simultaneously defied traditional gender norms and fulfilled them in ways that proved not only celebratory, but were also memorialized by those who witnessed her selfless actions.

Josephine Rogers’s small farmhouse was located on the edge of the Emmitsburg Road, south of Gettysburg. It was owned by her relatives, Peter and Susan Rogers. There is some dispute as to Josephine’s familial relationship with Peter and Susan. Some accounts list her as a niece, while others state she was a granddaughter or adopted daughter. Josephine would eventually marry her neighbor, William J. Slyder on October 25, 1863, with whom she soon moved to Ohio.  But on the second day of fighting, the entire Rogers family was still occupying their small farmhouse. As the violence began to intensify in the vicinity of the Rogers home, Union General J.B. Carr, commanding a brigade of New Yorkers stationed closest to the home, requested that Josephine and the Rogers leave immediately. However, 18-year-old Josephine refused to flee, telling the general she had a batch of bread baking in the oven. She reassured him she would leave after the bread was finished. This decision is lyrically described Harvard University graduate, Edgar Foster Davis’s poem published in 1912:

The war cloud is gath’ring o’er Gettysburg vale,

Portending hoarse thundering and death-dealing hail;

The solid earth trembles, and the rent is the air,

With the rushing of squadrons, —the loud trumpets blare.

The clanking of arms, and the shouting of men,

And the neighing of steeds from each echoing glen;

But unheeding the din and unhindered by dread

Josephine Miller is baking her bread.

Around 1:00 pm on July 2, General Daniel Sickles ordered the 3rd Army Corps to leave its position on Cemetery Ridge and move into the valley along the Emmitsburg Road, seeking to thwart a supposed Confederate march to Washington D.C. and move his troops to what Sickles considered to be a less vulnerable position along the high ground immediately above the Emmitsburg Road. The men of the 1st Massachusetts began to move into the Rogers’s fields and towards the farmhouse. At approximately 2:00, the men started to smell the scent of fresh bread, and as they arrived in position, they saw Josephine removing the loaves from the oven. Noting the soldiers’ desperate hunger, Josephine quickly sliced the loaves and distributed them to the Union soldiers. Three hours later, the Confederates open fired on the newly stationed 3rd Corps, bombarding the 1st Massachusetts, and Josephine Rogers, with shells. Despite the increasingly perilous situation, Rogers kneaded, baked, and sliced more loaves of bread for the troops. The officers offered her compensation, but she vehemently refused. To show their thanks, as Josephine’s flour supply dwindled, some soldiers volunteered to steal more from General Sickles’s commissary stores. They also returned with a supply of raisins, currants, and a sheep. Josephine Rogers stayed in her home for two days, not only feeding the soldiers, but also caring for the dying and wounded.

On July 3, the infamous artillery duel between the two armies shook the foundations of Josephine’s farmhouse. The Confederate infantry began to advance against the Union line, with some southerners marching directly through the Rogers’s fields. Just as General Carr had found Josephine hard at work by her stove, the Confederates incredulously noted Josephine Rogers once again baking bread amidst the hailstorm of lead flying about her.

Over the course of the now iconic Pickett-Pettigrew charge, many Confederate soldiers died near Josephine’s home. When the smoke had cleared, the home still stood but was marked with bullets and scarred by artillery shells. Seventeen bodies were removed from the farmhouse and the cellar. Additionally, many wounded soldiers, both Union and Confederate, had crawled into Josephine’s home to seek a haven from the bloody storm. Josephine cared for and comforted them as best she could, no matter what color uniform they wore.

Josephine Rogers, with her iron stove and loaf of bread, in front of the 1st MA monument (1886)

Josephine Rogers’s actions at Gettysburg symbolize both the breaking and fulfilling of traditional 19th-century gender roles. By obstinately refusing the orders and protective offers of powerful men and remaining in her home in the midst of battle, she directly contradicted the image of the meek and passive housewife who depended on masculine aid in the face of danger, and did not hesitate to attend to the mangled bodies of strange men. However, in other critical ways, she also fulfilled the roles expected of a 19th-century woman: She remained in her home to carry out her domestic responsibilities of baking, nursing the men under her roof, and (in true “Republican motherhood” style) literally propping up men to perform their “proper” civic and martial duties. Though she did all of this in spite of the horror and bullets swirling around her, Josephine represented the pinnacle of 19th-century feminine duty to home and to country. For both her defiance of and dedication to such gender norms, she earned a permanent place in the hearts of the men she interacted with on those two famous July days.

As the Civil War drew to a gruesome finale in 1865 and the nation struggled to heal, many people never knew about the heroic and altruistic actions of Josephine Rogers. However, the surviving troops of the 1st Massachusetts could not forget her. After the war, she was named an honorary member of the 3rd Corps, the only woman to receive such an honor. On July 2, 1886, when General Carr’s brigade reunited in Gettysburg, they invited Josephine Rogers to attend. They sought out her current whereabouts and mailed an invitation to her new home in Dayton, Ohio. Josephine agreed to travel back to her old home to once more to see the men she had aided. During the reunion, the Massachusetts men dedicated a monument to their unit’s actions at Gettysburg across the road from the Rogers’s house. Josephine was granted a privileged seat on the official ceremonial stand at the dedication. During the ceremony, some of the veterans moved the legendary black stove that Josephine had so famously used to bake bread for the soldiers under fire from the farmhouse and set it in front of the new monument. Josephine posed for a photo next to the stove with a loaf of bread in her hand. Josephine’s beloved stove has been lost to history, and the Rogers house no longer stands, having been torn down in the 1880s. Now, only a small plaque bearing the family name and a square-shaped picket fence remain to mark the homestead. Few people know the name or story of Josephine Rogers, but her heroic deeds speak to us over the generations from the memoirs and histories of the soldiers whose lives she touched, whose bodies she healed, and whose hunger she unflinchingly risked her life to quell; the import of her actions to those soldiers is forever enshrined in the rolls and records of the 1st Massachusetts, in the dedication speeches for the monument that still stands across the road from her homestead, and in the photos of her proudly posing by her stove with the veteran Bay Staters who made sure she would not be forgotten by history. Blending traditional 19th-century gender roles with the pragmatism necessitated by war, Josephine’s unlikely actions speak to her patriotism, but also her humanity, which she refused to sacrifice to the horrors and affronts of war. 

css.php